Why diet?
This is a question that I've been asked from time to time since I started my current weight loss journey. I actually have had to ask this of myself as well.
When I started this blog nearly a year and a half ago, I swore that I would never diet again. I was embracing dietary freedom and variety, sensory awareness of genuine hunger/satiety signals, and eschewing emotional eating. I was learning to navigate life without constantly striving to reduce my body size, which had been my default mode for most of my 40+ years.
Why, if restrictive eating plans had failed me throughout my life, did I feel inclined to try again? Isn't the definition of insanity to do the same thing over and over again, expecting a different result?
What changed?
I'm not entirely sure that I can really answer completely in a way that will be fully comprehensible to others. I'm not sure that I fully understand the reasons on a conscious level, myself.
Some of the reasons that I can identify are directly related to issues that I explored in this blog early on. The skills and ideas that I explored in posts like
Eat Only When Hungry,
Food Is Not Your Dog, and
The Zen of Eating showed me that, for someone like me, who has waged a lifelong battle with weight and eating, these things were actually hard work. Learning to operate my body as though I were naturally lean takes focus and determination. And, living inside a body that did not reflect my inner reality made me feel
insufficiently rewarded for my dedication. I felt as though I had been spending a year working really hard to declutter the inside of my house, but then realized that, in order for the effort to be worthwhile, I also wanted to repair the siding and give the outside of the house a fresh paint job.
Going back to my old habits was not an option. But continuing to live in a way where I felt that my outside and my inside were at odds with each other was no longer an option, either.
The irony of the matter is that I was not unhappy, not with myself, not with my life, not with my relationship with food or my body. I was in a place of contentment, where I was ready to embrace the joy in every moment, regardless of my appearance or body size. I have always been healthy and able to do active things, so it's not as if my physical size was an impediment in any way for the things that really matter in life. I have an unconditionally devoted Husband, who doesn't give a flyin' flip whether I wear a size 2 or 20, so it's not as if I felt that I needed to do this to please him. I felt really good about ME. My self-esteem wasn't staked on the number on the scale or the tag of my jeans.
My life was seriously full of awesome. And I was fully basking in all this awesome, avidly imbibing my sense of contentment with myself and my life, when I began pondering the possibility of changing my external appearance. The way I saw it, I had already worked on the issues which, when not addressed, lead dieters to regain the weight before they even reach their goal. I had already fixed the tendency to eat outside of hunger, eat to mask emotional issues, or eat mindlessly. I had also stopped the perpetual yo-yo cycle. Every person who has ever dieted knows how to be in "lose mode" or "don't care (gain) mode." But hardly anyone with a weight issue knows how to MAINTAIN.
Serendipitously, I came across a weight loss method that was radically different from anything that I had encountered before. The physiology of the method resonated with me, and the psychology behind the process presented the most logical approach I have encountered in my 30+ years of dieting.
I thought "I can do this. I already know how not to gain. If I can give my body a push to lose the weight, I can maintain out the other side without too much drama."
So, I decided to try it. Because it would be a fun experiment, and not getting the expected results wasn't going to crush me or diminish my sense of myself as entirely awesome.
I do not regret one minute of it.
The one heartfelt piece of advice that I would give anyone who is in despair over his or her weight is to step back from the dieting game for a good long time. Learn to live with yourself, and embrace the joy in life as if weight and size weren't an issue. Come to a place of peace with yourself, and learn to love yourself unconditionally. Abandon the self-hatred; it's never done you any good. Only when you are ready to embrace a life full of awesome, just as you are, will you be ready to make the big changes for yourself.
FOR YOURSELF.